Champagne Bar Review: Dom Perignon Never Said It

Champagne Bar Review: Dom Perignon Never Said It

Come quickly, I am tasting the stars. He did not say it. And he spent his career trying to get rid of the bubbles.

The Champagne Bar has fifty-five reviews and a 4.5, which as we have said perhaps twenty times across three hundred articles is not a rating, it is a rumour.

So we are going to talk about the drink, and about the most successful lie in the history of alcohol.

Come quickly, I am tasting the stars

Dom Perignon is supposed to have called this out to his fellow monks on discovering champagne.

He did not say it. There is no seventeenth-century source for it. It appears in the nineteenth century, in an advertisement, and it has been printed on packaging and repeated in toasts and quoted at weddings ever since.

It is one of the great pieces of marketing copy ever written and it is entirely fictional.

And he was trying to stop the bubbles

This is the part that finishes the story.

Dom Perignon was a real monk, a real cellarmaster, and a genuinely brilliant winemaker – and the bubbles were his problem, not his triumph.

A secondary fermentation in a sealed bottle produces gas. Seventeenth-century glass could not reliably contain it. Bottles exploded in the cellars, in chain reactions, and the men who worked there wore iron masks to protect their faces.

They called it le vin du diable. The devil’s wine. It was a fault.

Perignon spent decades working out how to prevent it – blending, pressing gently, harvesting early – and his real achievements are in blending and in the making of white wine from black grapes, which is a genuine technical feat and which nobody has ever put on a bottle.

The English, incidentally, liked the bubbles. They had stronger coal-fired glass and a taste for fizz, and there is a decent argument that sparkling champagne was perfected in London rather than in Champagne, which is a sentence that should not be said in France.

The Champagne Bar. He hated the bubbles. Genuinely.

The pattern, three hundred articles deep

We have found this in every single article of both surveys and we are no longer surprised by it.

The Elephant and Castle is a cutler’s badge and not a Spanish princess. The Churchill Arms was named forty-eight years before Winston was born. Old Speckled Hen is a car. Brydges Place is thirty-three inches and not fifteen. The Prince of Wales feathers were probably not taken from a blind king. Pop Goes the Weasel is about pawning your coat.

And the most famous quotation in the history of wine was written by an advertising man about a hundred and fifty years after the monk died.

In every single case the truth is technical, administrative or accidental, and the legend is beautiful, and the legend wins – because nobody has ever lost an argument by telling a better story.

Verdict

Fifty-five reviews. We cannot tell you a thing.

Go, order a glass, and raise it to Dom Perignon – who was a great winemaker, who never said the words on the bottle, and who spent his life trying to kill the thing he is famous for inventing.

One thought on “Champagne Bar Review: Dom Perignon Never Said It”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *