A 4.6 wine bar named after somebody nobody has asked about, which is now the fifth we have logged
Old Mary’s is a small wine bar with a hundred and eighty-one reviews and a 4.6, and it is named after a woman.
We do not know which woman. Nobody has asked. A hundred and eighty-one people have drunk here and the question has not once been raised in the public record.
The register
We have been keeping a list and it is time to read it out.
Gloria, in Covent Garden, who is blamed. For what, nobody says. There is a neon sign making a public accusation against her and she has never been given a right of reply.
Larry, in the coal vaults under the National Portrait Gallery, who is credited.
Manolo, on the Strand, whose house you are eating in.
Angie, in Notting Hill, whose pub is free.
Nell Gwyn, who has a tavern named after her that she never entered, and who went from selling oranges in a theatre to a dukedom for her son.
Biddy Mulligan, a widow with an apple stall in the Coombe, who is a song.
Alice Diamond, who ran the Forty Elephants and robbed the West End for two decades and has a cocktail bar and no statue.
And now Old Mary.
The finding
Across two hundred and sixty articles, this is the most consistent thing we have found, and it is not funny.
The women get the sign. Somebody else gets the licence. And in every single case, without exception, thousands of people have walked in, drunk, enjoyed themselves, left a review, and not one of them has asked who she was.
Meanwhile every man on a pub sign in this city has a plaque, a Wikipedia page, and a small industry of people repeating a fabricated story about him.
Wellington has four hundred pubs. Theodore Bullfrog never existed and has a whole article. The Earl of Lonsdale bankrupted an estate and we gave him six hundred words.
And Mary is just Mary, and she is old, and that is all anybody has recorded.
The bar
Which is genuinely very good, and which fits the pattern that has held across both surveys without a single exception.
Small room. Short list. Ten to twenty pounds, which for this postcode is honest. Somebody behind the bar who has tasted everything and wants to talk about it.
That is the formula. It is the only formula. It has produced every single high-rated venue in two hundred and sixty articles – Bedford Street Wines, the Clipper Lounge, Amaro, Kioku, Stables, Archive and Myth, Cepage[s] – and not one of them is famous.
Verdict
Excellent wine, warm room, fair prices.
Go. Ask what to drink. And then ask who Mary was, because somebody should, and in two hundred and sixty articles nobody has.
A note on “old”
It is doing work, and it is worth pausing on.
Old Mary. Not Mary. The adjective is affectionate and it is also, unmistakably, diminishing – the way a village refers to a woman it has known for fifty years and stopped seeing.
Compare the men. Nobody is Old Wellington. Nobody is Old Lonsdale. The Marquis of Granby is not Old Granby, and he bankrupted himself buying pubs for his soldiers.
The Prat is not going to build a thesis on a single adjective. We would simply note that in two surveys and two hundred and sixty articles, the only people on a sign who get called old are the women, and that Mary is presumably long dead and cannot object.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

The thing about satire in an age of maximum absurdity is you have to be more precise than the absurdity or you disappear into noise.
A Hackney politician said it was damaging democratic engagement because people understood voting didn’t affect predetermined outcomes. He didn’t ask if outcomes were predetermined.