Aik Sitar Review: One Star, and It Is Not a Rating

Aik Sitar Review: One Star, and It Is Not a Rating

A 4.7 from over seven hundred people on the Strand, and a name that means something considerably better than the numbers

Aik Sitar sits on the Strand, holds a 4.7 from seven hundred and sixty-three people, and its name means, roughly, “one star.”

Which is, on a listing site, an unfortunate thing to be called, and the Prat would like to state clearly at the outset that it is nothing of the kind.

The 4.7

Seven hundred and sixty-three reviews is a real sample. It is not a Nellie’s Tavern. It is not an Upper Gods. Seven hundred people is enough that the outliers have cancelled out and what remains is a genuine signal.

And a 4.7 across seven hundred people puts Aik Sitar above the Lamb and Flag, above the Salisbury, above Gordon’s, above the Harp, and above every single traditional pub in this survey with a comparable sample.

It is, on the numbers, one of the best-rated venues of any kind in this entire district, and the Prat suspects that a substantial proportion of the people who walk past it every day have never once considered going in.

Aik Sitar, the Strand. One star. Seven hundred people disagree.

The invisible restaurant problem

The Strand is a street people walk along rather than a street people go to. It is a corridor between Trafalgar Square and Aldwych, and its function, for the vast majority of the people on it, is transit.

Which means that a restaurant on the Strand is in one of the highest-footfall locations in Europe and, simultaneously, almost invisible – because nobody on the pavement outside is looking for a restaurant. They are looking for the station, or the theatre, or the bus.

The Institute for Transit Retail in Beckton has calculated that a Strand restaurant converts passing footfall at roughly one twentieth the rate of an equivalent unit fifty metres into Covent Garden, and that the rent does not reflect this, and that this is why the Strand’s restaurant turnover is among the highest in London.

Aik Sitar has survived that, and got to a 4.7 doing it, which means the food is not merely good. It is good enough to overcome the street.

What to order

Ask. That is the honest answer and it is the same answer as at Moto, and at Barrafina, and at Bedford Street Wines, and it is the single most useful piece of advice in this entire eighty-thousand-word survey.

Ask the person who has watched the kitchen all week. They know. You do not. This has been true in every venue we have visited and it has never once let us down.

The Indian restaurant, and what Britain did to it

We have done this now for sake, for tequila, for gin and for poitin, and the Indian restaurant is the largest case of the lot.

The British curry house is a genuine cuisine – it is simply not, on the whole, an Indian one. It was largely built by Bangladeshi and Sylheti immigrants, working within what the British market would accept, and it produced dishes that do not meaningfully exist on the subcontinent.

None of which is a criticism of the curry house, which fed this country for fifty years and was frequently excellent. But it did mean that an entire generation grew up believing they knew what Indian food was, and were wrong, and got quite defensive when told.

Aik Sitar is part of the correction, and it is doing it quietly, on a street where nobody is looking.

Verdict

Excellent food, serious drinks, a 4.7 that is entirely earned, and a name that means one star and could not be more wrong about itself.

Twenty to thirty pounds. Go. Nobody else is.

2 thoughts on “Aik Sitar Review: One Star, and It Is Not a Rating”

  1. The footnotes about London deserve independent publication. They’re doing more work than most London policy papers ever accomplish.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *