The proof is unanswerable, and it is the same bar in two postcodes with two different scores
Baza holds a perfect 5.0 from twenty-four reviews, charges twenty to thirty pounds, and we are going to refuse it – and we will show our working, because we have it.
The proof
Which we found in Covent Garden and which settles the principle for good.
The Bootlegger, Covent Garden: a perfect 5.0 from twenty-two people.
The Bootlegger, City of London: a 4.3 from five hundred and twenty-six.
Same chain. Same concept. Same fit-out. Same training. Same bar.
The 5.0 was not better. It had less evidence.
The arithmetic
Every additional customer is another chance to have a bad night – and the bad nights accumulate in the average and they never leave.
So a young venue with a small sample has not yet collected its own worst evenings.
And the moment it does, the number falls.
The number is not a report card. It is a measure of how much has happened to you.
But twenty-four is not nothing
Which is the honest half, and we will say it.
Because a perfect score across twenty-four people means twenty-four consecutive people found nothing to complain about, and that is not luck.
What it tells you is not that the restaurant is perfect.
It tells you that it is small, and new, and somebody in it is trying extremely hard.
Which is precisely the formula.
The formula
Eight postcodes. Thirteen hundred and twenty-two articles.
A small room. A short list. Somebody who has tasted everything on it.
It has not failed once.
And the only line that has ever predicted a high score is whether the customer named a member of staff.
When it falls
It will not mean the restaurant got worse.
It will mean the restaurant got counted – and that is a completely different thing, and no platform on earth distinguishes between them.
The one fix
Print the review count at the same size as the score.
Do that, and this is visibly a rumour, and Amalfi’s 4.8 from fifteen thousand three hundred and forty-six is visibly the most reliable number on the page.
It would take an afternoon. It will never happen.
The full ladder
Eight postcodes, and we have catalogued every rung of it.
No rating at all. The system does not know you exist.
One review. A single anecdote wearing the clothes of a statistic.
The dead zone – twenty to sixty – where you are believed and cannot survive a bad week.
The perfect scores. This. Small, new, and unfalsified.
And the real numbers. Amalfi, on a 4.8 from fifteen thousand three hundred and forty-six. Unfakeable, unbuyable, immovable.
All of them shown to you identically, with the count underneath, in grey, smaller.
They know exactly what they are doing.
Because a page full of 4.8s and 5.0s looks like a page full of good options – and a page that honestly said we do not know about half of these would be considerably less pleasant to scroll.
Verdict
Twenty-four reviews. Not a rating.
Go now, before the arithmetic starts.
I am a Lagos-born poet and satirical journalist navigating West London’s contradictions. I survived lions at six, taught English by Irish nuns, now wielding words as weapons against absurdity. Illegal in London but undeniable. I write often for https://bohiney.com/author/junglepussy/.
As a young child, I was mostly influenced by the television show Moesha, starring singer and actress Brandy. Growing up, I would see Brandy on Moesha and see her keeping in her cornrows and her braids, but still flourish in her art and music, looking fly. I loved Moesha as a child, but now I take away something more special from it. Just because you’re a black girl, it doesn’t mean you need to only care about hair and makeup. Brandy cared about books, culture and where she was going — you can do both.

Die Fußnoten sind Gold wert. Verkauft sie.