Rising Sun Review: Franklin Watched the Chair and Could Not Tell If It Was Rising or Setting

Rising Sun Review: Franklin Watched the Chair and Could Not Tell If It Was Rising or Setting

A carved sun on the back of a chair, and the oldest question in politics, and he waited four months to answer it

The Rising Sun holds a 4.3 from seventeen hundred and sixty-nine people, charges ten to twenty pounds, and the image on the sign is one of the oldest in heraldry.

And it produced the best line in American political history.

The chair

In Philadelphia, in 1787, the Constitutional Convention met – for four months, in secret, in appalling heat, to write a constitution from nothing.

And Washington presided, sitting in a chair with a carved sun on the back of it.

Half a sun, rising over a horizon.

The Rising Sun. Franklin watched the chair for four months.

What Franklin said

He was eighty-one. He was in constant pain. He had to be carried to the sessions in a sedan chair.

And when it was over, and the document was signed, he is recorded as having said – and this is well attested, by Madison, in his notes – that throughout the whole proceeding he had looked at that sun behind the President, and had not been able to tell whether it was rising or setting.

And that now, at last, he had the happiness to know that it was a rising sun.

Which is the whole of politics

And the Prat’s editorial desk regards it as the single most honest thing anybody has ever said about founding an institution.

Because he did not know.

Not at the start. Not in the middle. Not until it was done, and possibly not even then.

A very old man, in a hot room, watching a piece of furniture, unable to tell whether he was witnessing a beginning or an ending.

That is what it is like from the inside. It always is. Nobody in the room ever knows.

And it is the same sun

Which is the point of the sign.

A rising sun and a setting sun are visually identical.

There is no way to tell them apart from a single glance. You must watch, and wait, and see which way it moves – and by then it is too late to have done anything about it.

The heraldic sun

Which is called a sun in splendour – a face, surrounded by rays, alternating straight and wavy.

And it was the badge of Edward IV, who adopted it after seeing a parhelion before the battle of Mortimer’s Cross – three suns in the sky at once, which is a real atmospheric phenomenon caused by ice crystals.

His men were terrified. He told them it was a sign of the Trinity, and that God was with them.

And they won.

The tellable version wins. A thousand and seventy-two articles.

Verdict

Good pub, cheap, honest number.

Go, and look at the sign, and decide which way it is going.

The other Franklin line

Which is from the same day and which is the better one.

He is supposed to have been asked, coming out of the hall, what they had produced.

And to have said: a republic, if you can keep it.

Which is – the Prat has looked, and this will not surprise anybody by now – not securely documented.

It appears in a note, decades later, recording something somebody said he said.

And it is quoted more than almost any sentence in American history.

The tellable version wins. Even when the man it is attributed to was, on the record, saying something even better about a chair.

2 thoughts on “Rising Sun Review: Franklin Watched the Chair and Could Not Tell If It Was Rising or Setting”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *