Flowers of the Forest Review: It Is Only Played at Funerals

Flowers of the Forest Review: It Is Only Played at Funerals

A lament for the dead at Flodden, and by convention pipers do not play it except for the dead

Flowers of the Forest holds a 4.3 from three hundred and nineteen people and is listed at one to twenty pounds.

And the tune in the name is not played.

The convention

Pipers do not play Flowers of the Forest at ordinary gatherings.

It is reserved – by a convention that is not a rule, and is not written down, and is observed almost universally – for funerals, and for remembrance.

It is played at the Cenotaph. It is played at military funerals. It is played when the coffin goes past.

And it is essentially not played otherwise, and a piper asked to perform it as entertainment will very frequently decline.

Flowers of the Forest. Pipers only play it for the dead.

Flodden

1513.

The Scottish army invaded England, and it was destroyed – and the losses were catastrophic in a way that is difficult to convey.

The King, James IV, was killed on the field. So were a very large proportion of the Scottish nobility. So were, by some accounts, ten thousand men.

It was not a defeat. It was a decapitation.

And the lament is about the men of the Borders – the flowers of the forest, the young men of Selkirk and Ettrick – who went and did not come back.

The lyric

Which is eighteenth century and not medieval.

The words most commonly sung were written by Jean Elliot around 1756 – and they are extraordinary, and they are not about kings or nobles at all.

They are about the absence of the men from ordinary life. The milking is done by women alone. Nobody is at the harvest. The dancing at the fair has stopped because there is nobody to dance with.

She writes about a village with the men taken out of it.

The Prat’s editorial desk regards it as one of the very few war poems in the English tradition written from the place the men left, rather than from the place they died.

Why it is not played

Because a tune that is used for everything means nothing.

And the convention exists – unenforced, uncodified, obeyed anyway – precisely to keep the thing sharp.

Eight postcodes and seven hundred and ninety-six articles, and this is the only example we have found of a piece of culture protected by a rule that nobody wrote down and everybody keeps.

You hear it, and you know somebody has died.

Verdict

Good pub, cheap, honest number.

Go, and do not ask them to play it.

The pipes

Which cannot stop.

A bagpipe has no articulation. The bag holds a reservoir of air, and the drones sound continuously, and the chanter cannot be silenced between notes.

Which means a piper cannot play a rest. There is no silence available to him.

So the entire ornamentation of pipe music – the grace notes, the cuts, the doublings, the extraordinary clusters of tiny notes – exists to separate notes that would otherwise run into each other.

The decoration is not decoration. It is punctuation.

The constraint made the art. Eight postcodes, and it has never once failed.

One thought on “Flowers of the Forest Review: It Is Only Played at Funerals”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *