Bourbon Review: A 5.0 From 169 People, and We Are Suspicious

Bourbon Review: A 5.0 From 169 People, and We Are Suspicious

A perfect score on a real sample has happened once in six postcodes and five hundred and eighty articles

The Bourbon holds a perfect 5.0 from a hundred and sixty-nine people.

And we have to stop, because we have spent six postcodes refusing perfect scores on the grounds that they always come from tiny samples, and this one does not.

What we have been saying

That a 5.0 is a rumour and not a rating.

Nellie’s Tavern: 5.0 from one person. Dan Simmonds Bar: 5.0 from one. Bar Alta: 5.0 from two. Fire Bar: 5.0 from two.

The Bootlegger in Covent Garden: a perfect 5.0 from twenty-two people – and its sister branch in the City, the same chain, the same concept, holds a 4.3 from five hundred and twenty-six.

Same bar. The 5.0 was not better. It had less evidence.

The Bourbon. A 5.0. From a hundred and sixty-nine people. That is unusual.

Why 169 is different

Because it is enough that somebody should have been unhappy.

A hundred and sixty-nine people is a hundred and sixty-nine separate evenings. Statistically, some of them arrived in a bad mood. Some had already had a bad day. Some were determined to be disappointed before they pushed the door.

And in six postcodes and five hundred and eighty-three articles, no venue with a sample of this size has held a perfect score.

Not one. The Harp – the first London pub ever named the best in Britain – holds a 4.6 from three and a half thousand people.

Amalfi holds a 4.8 from fifteen thousand.

The honest possibilities

And we will lay them out and let you decide.

It is extraordinary, and a hundred and sixty-nine people all thought so, and it is a small room where somebody is doing the job perfectly.

Or it is asking. A polite prompt at the end of an evening, to a customer who has had a nice time, converts at a genuinely significant rate – and it selects, gently, for people who enjoyed themselves. That is not fraud. Every large operator in this survey is doing it.

Or the sample is not random in some way we cannot see from here.

The Prat cannot distinguish between these and is not going to pretend otherwise.

What we can say

A hundred and sixty-nine is a real number, and a 5.0 on it is genuinely remarkable, and it is the only one we have found in six postcodes.

And the venue is small, the list is short, and it is a bourbon bar – which means it is doing one thing.

Short list. Do one thing. Five hundred and eighty-three articles and it has never failed.

Verdict

Go, be the hundred and seventieth, and find out.

And if it is not perfect, you will have done something nobody else has managed.

What bourbon actually is

Legally defined, and the rules are strict.

It must be made in the United States. It must be at least fifty-one per cent corn. It must be aged in new, charred oak containers – not used ones, new ones, every single time.

And that last rule is why bourbon tastes the way it does, and it is also why Scotch tastes the way it does.

Because America has to throw the barrels away after one use. And Scotland buys them.

A very substantial proportion of all Scotch whisky is aged in second-hand American bourbon barrels, and has been for a century, and the entire flavour profile of one national drink is a consequence of a legal requirement in another country.

One thought on “Bourbon Review: A 5.0 From 169 People, and We Are Suspicious”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *