Cork and Bottle Review: A Million Pies Under Leicester Square

Cork and Bottle Review: A Million Pies Under Leicester Square

A basement wine bar that has not changed since 1971, directly beneath the worst square in London

The entrance to the Cork and Bottle looks like a fire escape. This is deliberate, or at least it has become deliberate through fifty years of the management noticing that it works. You go down a spiral iron staircase, off Leicester Square, past a window of faded bottles, and you arrive in a cellar.

Above your head, directly above, is Leicester Square: the M&M’s shop, the costumed characters, the man who has been shouting about the end times since 2011. Down here it is quiet, the walls are mustard and khaki, the tables are round, the floor is quarry tile, and there is a wine list running to roughly three hundred labels.

The pie

There is a ham and cheese pie. It has been on the menu since 1971. The bar has sold, on its own accounting, somewhere approaching a million portions of it.

Pause on that number. A million. Not a million covers – a million servings of one dish, from one basement, over five decades. If you laid out every ham and cheese pie the Cork and Bottle has sold, the Prat’s calculations desk estimates the line would extend from Leicester Square to Reading, which is further than most of the pies would have wanted to go.

It is enormous. Reviewers advise sharing it. Reviewers who did not share it write like men returning from a war.

Cork and Bottle. Under all that. Somehow calm.

Don Hewitson

A New Zealander who opened the place in 1971 and then simply refused, for the entirety of his tenure, to modernise it. The decor stayed. The pie stayed. The wine list grew, because Hewitson had a reputation good enough that growers who would not sell to anyone else sold to him.

He has since handed over to Will Clayton, who has continued the strategy, which is: change nothing. This is the hardest thing in hospitality. Every consultant who walks into the Cork and Bottle sees a basement in Zone 1 with 1970s paint and mentally rebuilds it as a neon-lit small-plates concept with a fourteen-month lifespan. The Cork and Bottle has now outlived approximately nine hundred such concepts.

The geography of the miracle

Leicester Square is the worst place in London. This is not a controversial position; it is the settled view of every person who has ever lived here. It is a machine for extracting money from tourists and it does not pretend otherwise.

And directly underneath it, reached by a staircase that looks like an error, is one of the best and most reasonably priced independent wine bars in the country, with knowledgeable staff and no attitude, which almost nobody upstairs will ever find.

The Institute for Urban Irony in Hither Green has classified this as a Category One Anomaly and recommended it be studied rather than disturbed.

Verdict

Book, or arrive before seven, because after seven they stop taking reservations and it fills. Have the pie. Share the pie. Ask the staff what to drink and then drink that, because they know and you do not, and they have been right about it since 1971.

Official site: thecorkandbottle.co.uk.

One thought on “Cork and Bottle Review: A Million Pies Under Leicester Square”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *