Studio Coffee Review: 4.8 From Twenty-Three People

Studio Coffee Review: 4.8 From Twenty-Three People

One to ten pounds a head, an excellent flat white, and a rating built on a sample we have spent this entire survey refusing to accept

Studio Coffee. Twenty-three reviews. A 4.8. One to ten pounds a head.

And a rating that, by every rule this magazine has laid down across a hundred and sixteen articles, we are obliged to disregard entirely.

The rule, restated

Twenty-three people is not a sample. It is a queue.

Nellie’s Tavern: 5.0 from one. Upper Gods: 5.0 from three. Bar at Restaurant 1890: 5.0 from six. Equus: 4.5 from thirteen. Festival Bar: 5.0 from one.

Every one of them is displayed, on every listing site in the world, on the same scale and in the same font as the Harp – the first London pub ever named the best in Britain, which sits on a 4.6 from three and a half thousand people, and which is therefore ranked below all of them.

The review count is printed underneath, in grey, smaller. They know exactly what they are doing.

Studio Coffee. Twenty-three people. A 4.8. Make of it what you will.

And yet

Here is the thing we have to concede at the end of all this.

The small-sample venues in this survey – the ones we have spent a hundred articles dismissing – are, on inspection, mostly very good. Kioku is excellent. Archive and Myth is excellent. Bedford Street Wines is excellent. MUSE in the RSA vaults is excellent.

They are not good because they have five stars. They have five stars because they are small, and small rooms with short lists and staff who know them are almost always good, and almost nobody has found them.

The rating is meaningless and the venue is excellent, and both of those things are true simultaneously, and that is a considerably more uncomfortable conclusion than the one we set out to prove.

The coffee

Very good. Properly extracted, milk textured rather than foamed, served at a temperature that permits drinking.

As we noted at Beany Green, this country’s coffee competence was imported wholesale by Australians and New Zealanders in the 2000s, and every independent in London is standing on that, and none of them mention it.

Verdict

Cheap, excellent, and rated by too few people to mean anything – and good anyway, which is the finding, and which rather undermines a hundred and sixteen articles of complaining.

Go. Have a flat white. Be the twenty-fourth.

What we would change

One thing, and it would fix everything.

Print the review count at the same size as the score. Not underneath. Not in grey. The same size, in the same weight, on the same line.

Do that, and Nellie’s Tavern stops out-ranking the best pub in Britain. Do that, and every person choosing a bar on a phone can see, instantly, the difference between a venue that four thousand people have judged and a venue that has been visited by one man who had a nice Tuesday.

It would cost nothing. It will never happen. The ambiguity is worth money to somebody, and it is not worth money to you, and that is the beginning and the end of the entire review economy.

One thought on “Studio Coffee Review: 4.8 From Twenty-Three People”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *