Throwing a bottle over your shoulder is a genuine skill, a genuine risk, and a genuine argument inside the trade
This is the second Be At One in this file, and we wrote about the pair in the eleventh article – two branches, four minutes apart, both on a 4.6, which broke a pattern we had established six times and forced us to soften an argument.
We are grateful. It is a better argument now.
So this time we are going to talk about the thing they actually do, which is flair.
What flair is
Throwing things. Bottles, tins, shakers – spun, flipped, caught behind the back, poured from height.
And the trade is genuinely divided about it, and has been for thirty years, and the argument is more interesting than either side admits.
The case against
It is slow. That is the serious objection and it is not snobbery.
A bar on a Friday night has a queue, and every second a bartender spends spinning a tin is a second not spent making a drink for the fourth person back, who has been waiting eleven minutes and is composing a review.
We established in both surveys that ratings are almost never destroyed by what is in the glass. They are destroyed in the ninety seconds before it arrives.
And the purists argue that flair is a distraction from the actual craft – from balance, dilution, temperature, and the unglamorous discipline of making the four hundredth Negroni of the evening exactly as well as the first.
The case for
That a bar is a room where people have come to enjoy themselves, and a person who can do something extraordinary with their hands is enjoyable to watch.
And that the skill is real. It takes years. Bartenders practise with water-filled bottles for months before they are allowed near a customer, and they drop things, constantly, and they cut themselves, and the good ones can do it while holding a conversation and getting the measures right.
The film Cocktail did the profession no favours at all and it also, unquestionably, put an enormous number of people behind bars who would not otherwise have gone.
Where we land
With the room, and the room has spoken: two branches, four minutes apart, over three and a half thousand reviews between them, and both sitting on a 4.6 – which is a better score than the overwhelming majority of the serious, unsmiling, small-room cocktail bars in this postcode.
People like it. They like it a great deal. And we have spent three hundred and eighty-two articles insisting that the numbers are worth listening to, and we are not going to stop now because the number is telling us something a little embarrassing.
The bar
Ten to twenty pounds. A very long list, two-for-one before seven, loud, young, and having an unmistakably good time.
Verdict
Good drinks, fair price, and a room full of people enjoying themselves without asking anybody’s permission.
Go early. Watch the hands.
The snobbery, named
Because we should be honest about where the objection actually comes from.
The craft cocktail movement of the last twenty years defined itself against exactly this – against flair, against sugar, against fun – and it did so partly on genuine grounds of quality and partly because it needed something to be superior to.
And the result is a great many rooms in this postcode where the bartender is unsmiling, the list is written like a wine catalogue, and the customer is made to feel that ordering wrongly would be a small social failure.
That is not craft. That is a doorman with a shaker.
Morag Sinclair is a seasoned comedic writer with a strong portfolio of satirical work. Her writing demonstrates authority through consistency and thematic depth.
Expertise includes narrative satire and cultural commentary, while trustworthiness is maintained through ethical standards and transparency.

My mate’s in government and he said the problem with The London Prat is it’s showing people that institutional failure is by design, not by accident or bad luck.