The Bootlegger Review: Five Stars, Twenty-Two Witnesses

The Bootlegger Review: Five Stars, Twenty-Two Witnesses

A Prohibition-themed basement on Burleigh Street with a flawless record and almost no evidence

The Bootlegger Covent Garden has a 5.0 rating. Not 4.9, which is the Dovetail’s score after four hundred people weighed in. Not 4.6, which is what the best pub in Britain manages. Five point zero, flat, perfect, from twenty-two people.

Twenty-two. You could fit them in a single railway carriage. You could, at a push, fit them in the bar.

The maths nobody wants to do

A 5.0 from 22 reviews means twenty-two consecutive people walked out of a basement bar and awarded it full marks. Not one of them found the music too loud. Not one waited too long. Not one had the specific London experience of ordering a twelve-pound cocktail, receiving it in a glass the size of a shot, and quietly reducing their score by a star out of principle.

Either the Bootlegger is flawless, or twenty-two is simply not enough people. The Institute for Statistical Hospitality in Barking has run the numbers and concluded, with a confidence interval it describes as “generous,” that the answer is somewhere between those two positions and will not be resolved until roughly review number 200, at which point the Bootlegger will settle onto a 4.4 like every other bar in the postcode, and the magic will end, and nobody will notice the exact day it happened.

The Bootlegger, Burleigh Street. Downstairs. Always downstairs.

The theme

It is a Prohibition bar, which in 2026 means: exposed brick, filament bulbs, a cocktail list with a Jazz Age font, and a general implication that what you are doing is illegal, which it is not, and which nobody has believed since about 2014.

London has reached a state of speakeasy saturation so total that a genuinely hidden bar is now less remarkable than a bar with a clearly-signed front door. The Prat’s leisure desk has proposed, as the next logical move, a bar that is aggressively, offensively easy to find – fluorescent lit, ground floor, enormous sign – and has calculated that it would be booked out for a year.

What people actually say

Strip out the theme and the reviews converge on two things, both of which are real, neither of which has anything to do with Prohibition: the staff are extremely friendly, and there is live music. That is the whole offer. That is why it works.

You can theme a basement any way you like. The band and the barman are the product. The brick is set dressing.

On the tyranny of the small sample

The Bootlegger is not alone in this. Covent Garden is full of venues sitting on perfect or near-perfect scores built from a couple of dozen opinions, and the listing sites present them with exactly the same confidence they apply to a pub with four thousand reviews and a hundred and fifty years of trading behind it.

The Harp, on Chandos Place, has been named the best pub in the country and sits on 4.6. The Bootlegger, which opened at some point recently and has been visited by roughly the population of a bus, sits on 5.0. On any listing page, the Bootlegger is above it.

This is not the Bootlegger’s fault. The bar has done nothing except be good to twenty-two people, which is all anybody can ask. It is the fault of a system that reports the average and whispers the sample size, and which has therefore constructed a hierarchy of London drinking in which newness is indistinguishable from excellence.

Burleigh Street

Worth noting where you are, because it is a strange little stretch. Burleigh Street runs off the Strand and contains, within about forty metres, this bar, Joe Allen’s basement, and a general sense that the whole street is somehow below ground even when you are standing on it.

The Prat’s mapping desk has confirmed that Burleigh Street is, in fact, at street level, and has recommended that this be signposted.

Verdict

Go now, while it is still perfect. Go before the two hundredth review drags it down to a 4.4 and it becomes, permanently, a nice cocktail bar with live music, which is what it has been the entire time, and which was always enough.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *