Blacks Review: The Private Members Club Is a Licensing Loophole

Blacks Review: The Private Members Club Is a Licensing Loophole

They exist because the pubs used to close in the afternoon, and the entire institution is built on that gap

Blacks Club is on Dean Street, has two hundred and thirty-nine reviews and a 4.4, and it is a private members’ club in a Georgian townhouse.

And the entire institution it belongs to exists because of a gap in a licensing act.

The loophole

For most of the twentieth century, English pubs closed in the afternoon.

The restrictions were introduced during the First World War, specifically to stop munitions workers drinking at lunchtime, and they survived – in essence – until 1988 for the afternoon gap and until 2005 for everything else.

Which meant that from about three until half past five, in the middle of the day, you could not buy a drink in a pub in England.

Unless you were a member of a club.

Because a club is not selling you a drink. A club is a group of members who collectively own the stock, and you are drawing on it, and the law regarded that as a completely different transaction.

Blacks. The club exists because the pub had to shut.

Which is why Soho has so many

Because Soho was full of people whose working day did not resemble anybody else’s.

Actors, who were free in the afternoon and working at night. Film people, whose entire industry was on Wardour Street. Writers, who could work whenever they liked and mostly did not. Musicians.

And all of them wanted a drink at four o’clock, and none of them could have one.

So they formed clubs. The Colony Room, which we wrote about, and which Muriel Belcher opened in 1948 and ran from a stool by the door, insulting everybody who came up the stairs – and which paid Francis Bacon ten pounds a week to bring his friends.

The Gargoyle. The Groucho. The French House upstairs.

Every one of them a room where you could drink at four in the afternoon, because you had paid a subscription.

And the loophole closed

In 2005 the licensing laws changed, and the pubs could open all afternoon, and the single functional reason for a members’ club in Soho evaporated.

And they did not close. They multiplied.

Because it turned out that the drink was never the point – and that what people had actually been buying, all along, was a room where the same faces were, and where you would not have to explain yourself to a stranger.

The Prat’s sociological desk regards this as the most instructive accident in five postcodes: an institution built entirely on a legal technicality, which outlived the technicality by decades, because it had been solving a different problem all along and nobody had noticed.

Verdict

Lovely house, good food, and a members’ club that no longer needs to be one.

The French House

Which is the other great Soho survivor and which deserves a line, because its rules are the best in London.

No music. No television. No mobile phones. And – the famous one – no pints. Beer is served in half-pints only, all year, to everybody, with a single exception on April Fools’ Day.

De Gaulle drank there. The Free French had their headquarters nearby and the pub became their unofficial mess, and there is a plaque.

Dylan Thomas left the only manuscript of Under Milk Wood under a chair in it, and it was found by the landlord, and returned.

He had no copy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *