Newman Arms Review: Orwell’s Pub and a Very Disturbing Film

Newman Arms Review: Orwell’s Pub and a Very Disturbing Film

George Orwell put it in two novels and Michael Powell filmed a murder there. A busy little pie pub with a dark CV.

The Newman Arms is a small pie pub off Rathbone Street, holds a 4.4 from four hundred and forty-four people, and has a literary and cinematic CV out of all proportion to its size.

Orwell’s pub

George Orwell drank here – he lived and worked in Fitzrovia, and this was one of his locals – and he put the pub, or a version of it, into his writing twice. It appears as the model for the proletarian pub in Nineteen Eighty-Four, the one Winston Smith ducks into, hoping to find some authentic memory of the past among the “proles,” and it echoes through Keep the Aspidistra Flying as well.

Orwell was fascinated by pubs. He wrote a famous essay imagining his perfect one, the Moon Under Water, an entirely fictional pub with the ideal fire, the ideal barmaid, and the ideal absence of a radio. The Newman Arms was one of the real pubs that fed that fantasy, and you can drink in it, which you cannot do at the Moon Under Water, because Orwell made that one up.

The Newman Arms. Orwell’s local. And a crime scene.

Peeping Tom

Now the dark part. In 1960 the director Michael Powell – one of the greatest British filmmakers, the man behind The Red Shoes and A Matter of Life and Death – made a film called Peeping Tom, about a murderer who films his victims as he kills them. The Newman Arms appears in it. A murder is set here.

The film was so disturbing to 1960 audiences and critics that it effectively destroyed Powell’s career overnight. It was savaged, pulled, and treated as a moral outrage, and one of Britain’s finest directors was more or less unemployable for years afterwards. It is now regarded as a masterpiece and a foundational work of psychological horror, and its rehabilitation came far too late to help Powell.

The Prat’s cinema desk notes that this little pie pub is bound up with both the most famous dystopia in the English language and one of the most notorious horror films ever made in Britain, and that it sells, in the middle of all that darkness, a very good pie.

The pie

The Newman Arms has been, for much of its life, a pie pub – a small, specialist operation doing proper British pies in an upstairs room, the kind of focused, unpretentious offer that Orwell would have thoroughly approved of.

A 4.4 across four hundred and forty-four people is a solid, genuine score, and the reviews are consistent: small, cosy, historic, good pies, a proper Fitzrovia local doing an honest trade.

Verdict

A tiny, excellent pie pub with a CV that includes the most famous dystopian novel in the language and a horror film that ended a great director’s career.

The Moon Under Water

Orwell’s imaginary perfect pub, the Moon Under Water, had ten specific qualities he prized: Victorian fittings, no music, a garden, good cheap food, barmaids who knew the regulars by name, and a quiet in which conversation was possible. He confessed at the end of the essay that no real pub had all ten, and that the Moon Under Water did not exist.

The Newman Arms has several of them – the smallness, the food, the lack of a blaring soundtrack, the proper local feel. It is closer to Orwell’s ideal than most, which is presumably why he drank here and put it in his books, and it is a rare thing to be able to visit the source of a great writer’s fantasy of the perfect pub.

Verdict

A tiny, excellent pie pub with a CV that includes the most famous dystopian novel in the language and a horror film that ended a great director’s career.

Go, have a pie in Orwell’s local, and try not to think about Peeping Tom while you do it. Winston Smith would understand.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *