Brook Green Review: 4.7, and a Green That Survived

Brook Green Review: 4.7, and a Green That Survived

Most of London’s commons were enclosed and built on. This one was not, and there is a pub on the edge of it.

Brook Green holds a 4.7 from two hundred and seventy-one people, which is one of the strongest scores in the file, and it sits on the edge of an actual green.

A real one. Grass, trees, a cricket pitch, dog walkers, and children. In London. Not fenced, not private, not locked, and not available only to the residents of the surrounding terraces.

Why that is remarkable

Because most of them are gone.

Common land in England was not public property in the modern sense – it was land over which local people held specific rights: to graze animals, to gather firewood, to cut turf. Those rights were ancient, they were real, and for a great many households they were the difference between subsistence and destitution.

And between roughly 1750 and 1850, Parliament passed several thousand Enclosure Acts, and the commons were fenced, divided, and handed to private owners.

Millions of acres. The rights were extinguished. The people who had relied on them were, in a great many cases, driven off the land entirely – and a substantial part of the population of Victorian London consists of their grandchildren.

Brook Green. It is still a green. Almost none of them are.

The Notting Hill version

Look at the crescents. We wrote about them at the Ladbroke Arms – the shape of a failed racecourse, built over in the 1840s.

Every one of those crescents encloses a communal garden. They are beautiful, and they are behind railings, and they are locked, and the key belongs to the houses.

That is enclosure, performed at a smaller scale, in a city, and it is the single most valuable amenity in W11, and we noted it at the Elgin and again at the Scarsdale.

Brook Green is the alternative that mostly did not happen. Open ground, in an expensive district, that anybody may walk on.

The pub

Twenty to thirty pounds. A 4.7 from two hundred and seventy-one people, which is a real number on a real sample and puts it alongside Akoya and Wild – and every venue in that bracket, across both surveys, has turned out to be the same thing.

Small. Well run. Somebody in charge who cares. No theme, no rope, no concept.

Verdict

Excellent pub, and the rarest amenity in London outside the door: ground that belongs to nobody and is therefore available to everybody.

The rhyme

There is an eighteenth-century verse about enclosure and it is the best thing anybody has ever written about property law.

The law locks up the man or woman who steals the goose from off the common – but leaves the greater villain loose who steals the common from the goose.

Nobody knows who wrote it. It circulated anonymously, in pamphlets and in pubs, during exactly the period when several thousand Acts of Parliament were transferring millions of acres from common right into private hands.

It is four lines. It has outlived every one of those Acts.

Verdict

Excellent pub, and the rarest amenity in London outside the door: ground that belongs to nobody and is therefore available to everybody.

Go, eat, and then sit on the grass, which you are allowed to do, which is the whole point, and which almost nowhere else in this survey permits.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *