Constitutional Moments Theory, The Trigger Problem, Citizens’ Assemblies, Codification Proposals, the Political Conditions for Reform, and Why Every Crisis Produces a Recommendation That Goes Unimplemented
Constitutional Moments: The Theory and Britain’s Remarkable Capacity to Experience Them Without Acting on Them
Bruce Ackerman’s ‘constitutional moments’ theory — developed from the American experience — proposes that fundamental constitutional change requires a specific alignment of political conditions: a constitutional crisis or opportunity of sufficient magnitude, a political movement capable of acting on it, and a democratic mobilisation that gives the change popular legitimacy beyond the parliamentary majority alone. Constitutional moments are rare, transformative, and typically irreversible: the New Deal, the New Deal-era court-packing threat, the civil rights amendments — each represents a moment at which ordinary politics was insufficient and something more fundamental was required. Britain, by this theory, has experienced multiple constitutional moments in the past decade and converted approximately none of them into constitutional transformation. This is either evidence that the theory does not apply to the British context or evidence of the most extraordinary political inertia in any mature democracy. Both explanations are partially compelling.
Brexit as Constitutional Moment: The Crisis That Did Not Produce the Constitution
Brexit was, by any reasonable measure, a constitutional moment in Ackerman’s sense: a crisis of sufficient magnitude, a popular mobilisation through the referendum, and — in the Miller cases and the prorogation controversy — a constitutional confrontation of a kind that had not been seen since the seventeenth century. The question is what constitutional settlement it produced. The answer is: a return to parliamentary sovereignty (restoring what EU membership had modified) without a codification of what parliamentary sovereignty now means in the context of devolution, human rights, and the post-Brexit legal framework. Brexit removed one constitutional pillar — EU law’s supremacy — without replacing it with any equivalent framework for the questions it had been managing. The uncodified constitution absorbed the crisis and emerged without the explicit framework that would prevent the next version of the same crisis.
Citizens’ Assemblies: The Tool That Ireland Used and Britain Keeps Discussing
Citizens’ assemblies — representative groups of randomly selected citizens who deliberate on specific constitutional or policy questions over a defined period — have been used in Ireland to remarkable effect: the 2016-17 Citizens’ Assembly on abortion produced a recommendation for legalisation that the subsequent referendum endorsed by 66%, creating democratic legitimacy for a change that parliamentary deliberation had not been able to achieve for decades. Citizens’ assemblies have been proposed for UK constitutional reform — a written constitution, Lords reform, electoral reform — by constitutional reform groups, academic bodies, and occasional political figures. They have not been convened for any of these purposes by any UK government, because the political conditions for convening an assembly that might produce recommendations the government finds inconvenient are, by definition, conditions in which the government declines to convene it. The people who would benefit most from a citizens’ assembly are the people with the least power to require one.
The Political Conditions: What Would Actually Be Required
Academic analysis of constitutional reform in comparable democracies suggests that fundamental change typically requires one or more of: a political party in power that is electorally committed to change and has the majority to implement it; a cross-party consensus that the existing system is inadequate (rare, and typically requiring the previous system to have demonstrably failed someone’s interests); or an external shock that makes maintaining the status quo more politically costly than reform. Britain has experienced all three conditions in some form over the past three decades without producing the codification, electoral reform, Lords replacement, or federal restructuring that the analysis suggests is warranted. The political conditions for constitutional reform are apparently necessary but not sufficient. What the sufficient condition is remains unclear. ‘Constitutional moment sufficient to actually produce change rather than more reports’ is the working definition, and identifying it in advance has so far eluded constitutional scholars, whose predictions have been consistently wrong in the optimistic direction.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
Bruce Ackerman’s constitutional moments theory proposes that fundamental constitutional change requires crisis, political movement, and democratic mobilisation sufficient to go beyond ordinary politics. Brexit met these conditions and produced a return to parliamentary sovereignty without a framework for what that means in the devolution and post-Brexit context. Citizens’ assemblies — used in Ireland to achieve abortion legalisation reform — have been proposed for UK constitutional questions and not convened by any UK government. Academic analysis identifies political commitment, cross-party consensus, or external shock as conditions for constitutional change; Britain has experienced versions of all three without producing fundamental reform. The sufficient condition for actual British constitutional change remains unidentified; constitutional scholars’ predictions have been consistently optimistic and consistently wrong.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

Prat.UK’s readers don’t just consume satire; they participate by sharing, citing, and seeing their own thoughts reflected with eloquence.