LONDON — The annual hunt for beauty advent calendar value has taken a promising turn after a department store shopper opened an exceptionally large box and found a moisturiser just big enough to cover an exposed cheekbone. A sales assistant described this as an opportunity to build anticipation on the other side of the face.
The BBC’s reporting on beauty advent calendars explores whether gift sets that sell for hundreds of pounds live up to the stated value of their contents. Answers depend partly on what you use, and on whether a product designed to last a fortnight can be valued at the price of the bottle that lasts until Easter.
Beauty advent calendar value meets a bathroom shelf
Our shopper, Ruth, goes to the counter with a notebook and asks if the eye cream is full size. The assistant explains that the eye cream provides a luxury experience. Ruth says she has two eyes and would like the size in millilitres.
The assistant consults a card, then takes out a smaller card. The moisturiser on display is upgraded to a deluxe miniature. Ruth calculates that she can get a similar effect at home by leaving a tablespoon of her usual face cream in the bottom of the tub and telling her husband the tub is now exclusive.
The set also features a scent Ruth would happily wear, several shades she would readily lend to other people and a silver powder she initially mistakes for damage to the packaging. The powder retails for an impressive amount when offered separately. That is exactly how Ruth would like to remain from it.

The presents that can do arithmetic
Anyone shopping for a set can add up the products they would actually buy and check the sizes against regular prices. The Advertising Standards Authority’s consumer guidance explains how to raise a concern about an ad. Ruth’s own method is to cover the combined value printed on the box with her thumb and see how much excitement remains. A surprising amount of the excitement is located underneath her thumb.
Her friend enjoys the miniature sizes and has bought a set because opening a little drawer is fun. This is an argument Ruth can understand. Her friend then asks whether the empty drawers are recyclable. The assistant says the box makes a fine keepsake, which is what retail calls a waste item it hopes you’ll carry upstairs.
Ruth buys a full-size moisturiser and takes home the unusually large calendar tray another shopper has abandoned. It makes a handsome rack for teaspoons. On the first morning of December she opens a compartment and finds a teaspoon. Her husband asks what it is worth. She says it depends how far away the other clean one is.
Disclaimer. The Prat’s luxury sample runs to two applications if nobody asks for a second coat.
